A new analysis shows that low turnout among Trump supporters caused the recent election loss. The data indicates that more than two-thirds of the "Blue Tsunami" was due to voters staying home. This finding comes from a survey of 1,000 registered voters conducted on Election Day. The poll was checked against over 30,000 interviews from the campaign season.
35% of Trump's 2024 voters did not cast a ballot on November 3.
Only 8% of Trump voters switched their votes to back Democrats. The absence of these voters alone accounts for 10 points of the swing toward Democrats. Voters who actually switched sides supplied the other five points of that swing. This means the election was lost because supporters simply did not show up to vote.
The numbers show a deep drop in participation among specific groups of Trump's base. 46% of Trump's 2024 voters lacking a college degree failed to cast a ballot. Also, 44% of voters over the age of 65 stayed home on election day. In rural areas, 39% of Trump's 2024 voters failed to cast their ballots.
Congress would have flipped due to low turnout alone. Absent any voter switching sides, the GOP still would have lost the House and Senate. Trump's claim that Republicans lost because his name was not on the ballot gains support from this finding. The day after the election, Vice President JD Vance wrote on X that "the main problem is not turnout." The polling data cuts against the case made by the Vice President.
James Johnson, the founding director of the firm J.L. Partners, led this analysis. He argued the GOP should not yet discard the MAGA baby with the bathwater. Johnson told The Post that "If Trump was on the ballot, you would have expected a better result." He believes the path forward is clear for the party.
"If Republicans can energize their 2024 vote in 2028, then they may yet have a shot at winning again," said Johnson. He emphasized that "That is how important turnout was at this election." The data suggests that the party does not need to change its message to win. It just needs to get its own people to the polls.
Some sources within the party are already looking at who might run in 2028. ABC News reported GOP sources saying the party prioritized culture wars over costs, losing key Latino voters. Doubt exists regarding whether JD Vance remains the presumptive 2028 nominee. Former RNC Chair Ronna McDaniel told ABC News she did not expect such a large shift.
"I thought that we were going to keep the Senate," McDaniel said. She added, "I didn't think that Democrats could make inroads in states like South Carolina and Kansas and even Texas." The data shows that Democrats did more than just make inroads. They capitalized on the fact that Republicans did not turn out their base. The focus now shifts to how the party gets its voters back out in two years.